top of page
Search

Another AI film experiment: The Seat

Writer: Long Khuat
Long Khuat
Oct 17
7 min read

The Seat is another AI short, 55 seconds, vertical, with spoken English dialogue. The challenge I set was simple: a vertical drama of 45–60 seconds, made for a phone screen, with a real story in it, in English. That means a hook, a conflict, an escalation, a twist, and an ending that either lands or makes you want more.

Watch here:


Where the idea came from

I’ve made quite a few short films over the years, across a few genres. But there’s one genre I love and have never had the chance to make in the real world: mystery and thriller. AI makes that possible.

When I sat down to think of a story, the first image in my head wasn’t a plot. It was a place: the English countryside.

I did my MA in Hertfordshire. I remember getting off the train from London at night and cycling home, about fifteen minutes. The roads were completely empty, and there was a cemetery right next to one of them. It was quiet and beautiful, and a little creepy. I’ve never forgotten that feeling, and it became the tone and mood of this film. That’s also why, if you pause on the old bus ticket near the end, it says Hertfordshire Bus Service. A small wink to a place that has a special place in my heart.

The one-liner

At a lonely bus stop in the English countryside, an old man tells a woman that the seat she’s sitting on is taken.

Writing for a phone screen

Short-form video is ruthless. People decide whether to keep watching in the first second or two, so the hook has to come almost immediately. The first shot is a wide of the bus stop with the woman sitting alone. Then a close-up of her. Then, over her shoulder, there’s an old man sitting at the other end of the bench. He wasn’t there a moment ago.

That was built into the script, I wanted people to feel that something is wrong without being sure what. That uncertainty is what keeps them watching. It also works with the sound off, which matters, because a lot of people scroll on mute.

After that, every beat has to earn its place. In a longer film you can breathe. At 55 seconds, a shot that doesn’t move the story is a shot where someone swipes away. So I kept the bus stop slow and quiet to build tension, and then, once she gets on the bus, the shots get shorter and come one after another. The driver asks who she was talking to. She turns to the window. The bus stop is empty. Her face. Then the longest shot in the film: an old ticket on the bench, held long enough for you to read the date.

A few small decisions do a lot of the work:

  • His clothes are 1950s, but only just. A flat cap, a herringbone coat, a knitted tie. He reads as an old-fashioned gentleman, not a ghost. If his costume shouted “period piece”, you’d guess the ending in three seconds.

  • Her earphones are white and wired. They mark her as someone from today, and she has to take one out to hear him. It’s a small, physical way of saying these two people aren’t living in the same moment.

  • The ticket is in his hands early. At eleven seconds, there’s a close-up of his fingers turning an old bus ticket. Most people won’t think about it. But when it turns up on the bench at the end, anyone who rewatches will see it was there all along.

The smile

There’s a moment, after she leaves, when he turns to the empty seat and smiles. I first made a version where he smiles warmly, like a man remembering someone he loves. It fit the story. But the more I looked at it, the more I wanted the film to lean into the unease, so I chose a stranger, slightly creepy smile instead. He’s not a normal man, and I wanted the audience to feel that just before the twist, not only after.

It’s one of my favourite choices in the film, and it’s a good example of something I keep relearning: the right take isn’t always the one that matches the script. It’s the one that matches the tone.

Building it (briefly)

I won’t go deep into the tools this time; I covered most of my process in the Friend post. The basics were the same: clean reference sheets for the two characters, the ticket and the locations, so every shot pulls from the same faces, clothes and places.

The biggest change was how I used storyboards. On The Friend, I generated 9-frame storyboards and pulled my opening frames from them. This time the video model I used was expensive, so I used the storyboards as a rehearsal instead. Before paying for any video, I turned each scene into a cheap storyboard and looked at it like a test screening. Is he in the right seat? Is she looking the right way? Does the scene flow? If the storyboard was wrong, the video would have been wrong too, and it’s much cheaper to find that out on a still image.

I also wrote the whole film as three long prompts of about twenty seconds each, with the same fixed rules repeated in every one: where each person sits, which shoulder her bag is on, that the light never changes, how each voice sounds. The Friend had no dialogue, so voices were new to me. I expected them to drift from clip to clip and planned to fix them afterwards. But by describing each voice exactly the same way every time, they stayed consistent through the whole film.

Where the model fought back

About half of my first attempt was usable. The rest needed fixing, and a few problems are worth sharing.

The simplest-sounding thing was one of the hardest: who sits where. The film depends on three seats. He’s always on the left, her seat is on the right, and the middle one is always empty. The model kept moving him into the middle seat, or sitting them shoulder to shoulder. I had to spell the seating out in every single prompt, almost like a floor plan.

The shot I struggled with most is on the bus, when she turns to look back at the bus stop. She has to turn towards the window. No matter how I wrote it, she turned the other way. Writing “her left” didn’t work, and even describing it from the camera’s point of view (her head turning towards frame-right) didn’t work. In the end the fix was simple: I made the last frame of the shot as a still image, with her already facing the window, and gave the model both the first and the last frame. With the ending fixed, it only had to fill in the move.

My rule from The Friend held up again: if a shot fails two or three times, stop rewording the prompt and change the setup. Use a different starting image, an end frame, a simpler action, or a different model. Rewording the same request for the fifth time is usually just a slower way to fail.

The sound

Most of the sound came straight out of the generated clips: the wind, the bus, the voices. Because the film is stitched together from many different generations, the background sound jumped at almost every cut, so I spent real time in the edit mixing and cutting ambience from different clips until it felt like one continuous afternoon. There’s only one piece of music, a short suspense cue when we see the date on the ticket. The rest is wind and silence, which I think makes that one moment land harder.

What I’d do differently

  • The first two seconds are too quiet. A slow wide shot is how I’d open a film in a cinema. On a phone, it’s a risk. Next time I’d put something in that first second, like a sound or a line, to earn the next three.

  • The middle conversation could be tighter. There are about ten seconds of quiet dialogue where not much new happens on screen. I think the film would be better at 45–48 seconds.

The story behind the man

I didn’t want the film to explain this, and I still don’t. But since you’ve read this far, here’s what I had in mind.

In the early fifties, he took this bus home from work every evening. His wife would wait for him on that seat, and they’d walk home together. One evening, he didn’t get off the bus. No one ever found out why. She kept coming back, day after day, and waited on the same seat. She tied flowers to the pole of the bus stop for him. I think deep down she knew he was gone, but she couldn’t bring herself to believe it, so she just kept waiting.

He knew all of it, of course, and couldn’t tell her. So he sat beside her, all those years, until she passed away herself. And he’s still there. That’s why he tells a stranger her seat is taken. It isn’t his seat. It’s hers.

If you go back and watch it again, you’ll see the flowers on the pole.

The lessons

After a few films, I believe the same thing I believed after the first: the tools don’t make the film. What made this one work, where it works, were ordinary filmmaking decisions. Choosing a small conflict that carries a big one. Planting a clue and not pointing at it. Picking a creepy smile over a warm one. Holding a shot long enough for the audience to do the rest.

At the same time, I continue to be surprised by how fast these generative models are improving, and I’m excited to keep learning and growing alongside them, to see how far they go.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page